Cotati Rancho is a circa-1950 Penngrove tract of 14 homes. Every home and recorded sale in it is indexed below.
| Address | Type | Specs | Lot sq ft | Last sale |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1830 E Railroad Ave | Property | — | 699,138 | $750K · 2025 |
| 485 Elysian Ave | Property | 2,231 sf · built 1954 | 987,505 | $2.5M · 2024 |
| 11830 Main St | Property | 3,804 sf · built 1918 | 13,884 | $1.15M · 2022 |
| 8560 Petaluma Hill Rd | Single family | 2 bd · 2 ba · 1,157 sf · built 1890 | 261,360 | $585K · 2020 |
| 10435 Old Redwood Hwy | Multi-family | 2 bd · 1 ba · 900 sf · built 1950 | 182,516 | $2.35M · 2017 |
| 0 Main St | Vacant land | — | 302,742 | $120K · 2016 |
| 8925 Petaluma Hill Rd | Multi-family | 2 bd · 2 ba · 1,470 sf · built 1910 | 41,907 | $254K · 2005 |
| Address | Type | Specs | Lot sq ft | Last sale |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 Main St | Vacant land | — | 302,742 | $120K · 2016 |
| 400 Formschlag Ln | Mobile home | 80 sf | 174,240 | — |
| 485 Elysian Ave | Property | 2,231 sf · built 1954 | 987,505 | $2.5M · 2024 |
| 595 Highland Ave | Single family | 3 bd · 1 ba · 1,280 sf · built 1949 | 50,093 | — |
| 1830 E Railroad Ave | Property | — | 699,138 | $750K · 2025 |
| 3914 Lichau Rd | Property | 3 bd · 4 ba · 2,034 sf · built 2014 | 2,350,933 | — |
| 5836 Old Redwood Hwy | Single family | 1 bd · 1 ba · 840 sf · built 2007 | 85,377 | — |
| 6061 Ronsheimer Rd | Single family | 2 bd · 1 ba · 1,016 sf · built 1940 | 30,491 | — |
| 8250 Petaluma Hill Rd | Property | — | 2,188,890 | — |
| 8560 Petaluma Hill Rd | Single family | 2 bd · 2 ba · 1,157 sf · built 1890 | 261,360 | $585K · 2020 |
| 8718 Petaluma Hill Rd | Single family | 2 bd · 2 ba · 1,398 sf · built 1960 | 24,000 | — |
| 8925 Petaluma Hill Rd | Multi-family | 2 bd · 2 ba · 1,470 sf · built 1910 | 41,907 | $254K · 2005 |
| 10435 Old Redwood Hwy | Multi-family | 2 bd · 1 ba · 900 sf · built 1950 | 182,516 | $2.35M · 2017 |
| 11830 Main St | Property | 3,804 sf · built 1918 | 13,884 | $1.15M · 2022 |
Run this neighborhood’s numbers for your home: ask Jake what it is worth, and see what you’d walk away with.
Free · save your work with a free account · no obligation. An automated valuation and a broker’s opinion of value are different things — the difference, explained.
Realtor, CA DRE #02070119. One licensed agent runs The Penngrove Market: publishes the record, answers the questions and takes the calls. No listing required, no obligation.